I mentioned this below but just saw you commented on what I had originally said. It’s not an apples to apples comparison ie Saban’s loss to Louisiana Monroe in his first season versus DeBoer’s to Vandy. Saban took over a bad team filled with players who didn’t know how to win. DeBoers was given an elite roster filled with NFL caliber players at every level. And those players know what winning takes. But I’ll give you some rope. Are you saying DeBoers needs time to build a roster? Or that he needs time to get adjusted to the SEC? I’ll buy the second but that too is different from Saban. Saban knew what it took to win in the SEC he just had to recruit players who could win in the SEC. DeBoers has the players … how long do you think it will take him to learn how to use them to win in the SEC? Other than the first half against Georgia, this team hasn’t looked like the Bama teams we were spoiled to watch play since 2008. Anyway, I’ve been saying the same thing since Saban resigned. It’s unfair to expect the coach who follows the GOAT to be another GOAT. Look I so hope DeBoers is it … but what are the chances Bama hired back to back GOATs? What to know why Bama has won NC’s in every decade since the 1920’s except for the 1950’s and 1980’s? It’s because Bama fans demand it. Auburn fans just want to beat Bama … Bama fans will only accept NC’s. DeBoers knew that when he took the job. The honeymoon at Bama only lasts a few weeks. It’s been more than a few weeks.
Interesting viewpoint. I don't agree that Saban took over a bad team - he took over a poorly coached team with lots of talent and there's a difference. As I posted elsewhere, the 2007 roster included; Terry Grant, Glen Coffee, Roy Upchurch, DJ Hall, Darius Hanks, Andre Smith, Mike Johnson, Brandon Deaderick, Wallace Gilberry, Josh Chapman, Rolando McClain, Eryk Anders, Prince Hall, Simeon Castille, Kareem Jackson, Rashad Johnson, Cory Reamer and Javier Arenas.
I'll give you some rope, too. I never said CKD needs time to build a roster. There's plenty of talent. But - just like Saban - he needs time to gel with his players and his new staff. To wit: The biggest single weakness in the second half against UGA and the game against Vandy was the defensive backfield. We lost 11 players from last year's squad from this group, including the best defensive backfield player in the country in Caleb Downs. We have young talent there on the roster, it will take more than 5 games for CKD and his staff to gel among themselves and gel with the players to produce better consistency.
I don't think this loss is any worse than the La Monroe loss. The big question is: How will they respond? That will determine what we look like down the road. There are A LOT of very young players on this team starting and getting significant playing time. And it's the NIL era. This is a tougher row to hoe than in the mid 2000s.
Saban is without question the GOAT and I've never seen a school replace a GOAT level coach with another GOAT level coach in succession. I don't expect that and I don't think most rational fans expect that either. But CKD is an excellent coach with a proven track record and I think he deserves more time than 5 games to show his full mettle.
PS - let's hope Saban doesn't give USCe and Tennessee any bulletin board material for those games!