🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs the osu

Good: Aside from the obvious, I want to point out how happy Saban was. I think it meant the world to him for these seniors that came back and accomplished every goal they set forth. Outside of Moses I think each one of them added much more value to their name and accomplished everything they came back for. Did you see how smitten Leatherwood was with that trophy?!? Seeing a guy known for his staunch behaviors, screaming at the end of blowouts, straight face competitiveness and even keel expressions, it meant so much to me to see him smile and open up to the happiness he knew his players felt and accomplished. That's why he's the best and will continue to get the big recruits.

Bad: I felt the call on Battle was absolute garbage. How else do you hit a guy that is 6'6-250 when you're 6'1-200? It's to the point where a defense is forced to let a guy catch the ball and then you're free to tackle him. To me it was a picture perfect hit, he separated the receiver from the ball, his head was up (not down like Herbstreit kept yammering about). It's human nature to tuck when putting all your force into something. I just feel like it's impossible to play defense anymore and we will be watching flag football in years to come. Offenses are out of this world in part due to these kinds of calls that keep drives alive and offenses scoring.

Ugly: DeVonta's fingers. Hate that it happened, but glad he will be alright. Glad he was able to showcase his amazing abilities before he dislocated them. He showed up on the big stage and did enough in a half to help his team win. A true Heisman winner.

Honorable Mention: Waddle, Waddle, Waddle. Can't say enough about him. Got the offense a major first down at the beginning of the game and caught a couple more. Just the grit and desire to be with his team and finish what he helped start. All of the Tweets from "professionals" telling him to quit pissed me off because all they think about is money and not even remotely concerned about what Waddle wanted. You know what, maybe his NFL future isn't a concern of his, maybe he wanted to enjoy one night out with his boys before it ended and life became business rather than pleasure. He did what he wanted, succeeded and will always be remembered as a competitor for us Alabama fans. We love him and appreciate his efforts, BIG TIME!
 
BamaFan334 said:
Good: Aside from the obvious, I want to point out how happy Saban was. I think it meant the world to him for these seniors that came back and accomplished every goal they set forth. Outside of Moses I think each one of them added much more value to their name and accomplished everything they came back for. Did you see how smitten Leatherwood was with that trophy?!? Seeing a guy known for his staunch behaviors, screaming at the end of blowouts, straight face competitiveness and even keel expressions, it meant so much to me to see him smile and open up to the happiness he knew his players felt and accomplished. That's why he's the best and will continue to get the big recruits.

Bad: I felt the call on Battle was absolute garbage. How else do you hit a guy that is 6'6-250 when you're 6'1-200? It's to the point where a defense is forced to let a guy catch the ball and then you're free to tackle him. To me it was a picture perfect hit, he separated the receiver from the ball, his head was up (not down like Herbstreit kept yammering about). It's human nature to tuck when putting all your force into something. I just feel like it's impossible to play defense anymore and we will be watching flag football in years to come. Offenses are out of this world in part due to these kinds of calls that keep drives alive and offenses scoring.

Ugly: DeVonta's fingers. Hate that it happened, but glad he will be alright. Glad he was able to showcase his amazing abilities before he dislocated them. He showed up on the big stage and did enough in a half to help his team win. A true Heisman winner.

Honorable Mention: Waddle, Waddle, Waddle. Can't say enough about him. Got the offense a major first down at the beginning of the game and caught a couple more. Just the grit and desire to be with his team and finish what he helped start. All of the Tweets from "professionals" telling him to quit pissed me off because all they think about is money and not even remotely concerned about what Waddle wanted. You know what, maybe his NFL future isn't a concern of his, maybe he wanted to enjoy one night out with his boys before it ended and life became business rather than pleasure. He did what he wanted, succeeded and will always be remembered as a competitor for us Alabama fans. We love him and appreciate his efforts, BIG TIME!
Click to expand...

With respect I will disagree with you on the targeting call on 9. I am not sure if you can use your shoulder pads when making a tackle in todays game but that was a real chance for 9 to level that TE had he stuck his shoulder in that belly instead of his headgear to headgear.
 
Last edited:
JoseyWalesTheOutlaw said:
With respect I will disagree with you on the targeting call on 9. I am not sure if you can use your shoulder pads when making a tackle in todays game but that was a real change for 9 to level that TE had he stuck his shoulder in that belly instead of his headgear to headgear.
Click to expand...

I can see both sides, but I guess I see targeting as intent to hit with the crown of your helmet or to hit another player up in the head as he is defenseless (IE quarterback or crack back blocks). I see it as if he hits that guy in the waste, Battle gets ripped in half as that's where the meat of that guy's body is and 250-270 is going to beat 200-210 every time. I did not see it as targeting, but I'm not an official and also a fan of the guilty party, so maybe my thought process is flawed.

Skalski on Fields was targeting as he was looking at the ground and in a spearing position not looking at what he was hitting.
 
JoseyWalesTheOutlaw said:
With respect I will disagree with you on the targeting call on 9. I am not sure if you can use your shoulder pads when making a tackle in todays game but that was a real change for 9 to level that TE had he stuck his shoulder in that belly instead of his headgear to headgear.
Click to expand...
@BamaFan334

looked like targeting to me....
Now...some are more forceful n dangerous than others...
But he snapped the receivers head back with his helmet....
Looked like he was trying to use the shoulder....but rode up high

and Skalskis hit was a deliberate use of helmet
 
50+yeartidefan said:
@BamaFan334

looked like targeting to me....
Now...some are more forceful n dangerous than others...
But he snapped the receivers head back with his helmet....
Looked like he was trying to use the shoulder....but rode up high

and Skalskis hit was a deliberate use of helmet
Click to expand...

And that's what I'm saying, how else do you hit a guy that is 6'6? His head snapped back, but he was hit more in the chest/neck area if I remember correctly. To me it's no different than a few hits Trevor Lawrence took when he is 6'6, tucked his head and a guy that's 5'10 gets called for targeting cause he hit Lawrence in the head after he tucked. It's just impossible. Why even wear a helmet anymore if you can't use it, responsibly. Want to cut it out, take helmets away from them and play rugby. Use your hands and you get dislocated fingers.

That looks like a clean stick and drive to me. I would be honored for my football team to form tackle like that. Watch the video. Zero launching either.

www.sportingnews.com

NFL players upset by Jordan Battle's targeting ejection during Alabama vs. Ohio State | Sporting News

NFL players upset by Jordan Battle's targeting ejection in Alabama vs. Ohio State
www.sportingnews.com www.sportingnews.com

1610468668570.png
 
50+yeartidefan said:
@BamaFan334

looked like targeting to me....
Now...some are more forceful n dangerous than others...
But he snapped the receivers head back with his helmet....
Looked like he was trying to use the shoulder....but rode up high

and Skalskis hit was a deliberate use of helmet
Click to expand...

It appears the refs are going to side with the receivers in their targeting calls....you use the headgear then you gone....use those 200 dollar shoulder pads for a change
 
BamaFan334 said:
And that's what I'm saying, how else do you hit a guy that is 6'6? His head snapped back, but he was hit more in the chest/neck area if I remember correctly. To me it's no different than a few hits Trevor Lawrence took when he is 6'6, tucked his head and a guy that's 5'10 gets called for targeting cause he hit Lawrence in the head after he tucked. It's just impossible. Why even wear a helmet anymore if you can't use it, responsibly. Want to cut it out, take helmets away from them and play rugby. Use your hands and you get dislocated fingers.

That looks like a clean stick and drive to me. I would be honored for my football team to form tackle like that. Watch the video. Zero launching either.

www.sportingnews.com

NFL players upset by Jordan Battle's targeting ejection during Alabama vs. Ohio State | Sporting News

NFL players upset by Jordan Battle's targeting ejection in Alabama vs. Ohio State
www.sportingnews.com www.sportingnews.com

View attachment 16470
Click to expand...
Ur picture shows the head gear being used......
Targeting calls are for protection of players...

that is classic targeting....
 
Looks like targeting to me. But I don’t agree with the ejection rule. Especially don’t agree with the ejection carrying to the next game if it’s in the second half.

I personally think it should be a 15 yard penalty and on second offense ejection not first offense
 
50+yeartidefan said:
Ur picture shows the head gear being used......
Targeting calls are for protection of players...

that is classic targeting....
Click to expand...

I guess I was always told to bury my face in a guys chest, back straight, and thrust into them while taking them down. Looks like what happened here for the most part. He does hit his face mask that is sticking out inches from his face and it caused his head to move. Whatever, doesn't matter in the end, but I still think it was a bad call and a lot of others see it both ways as well. We won, so no need to beat a dead horse.
 
Good: Everything on offense & most of defense

Bad: I thought Mac Jones should have won the offensive MVP. Smitty was amazing, but only played half the game. The 'O' kept pumping when he was out, and largely due to Mac Jones

Ugly: The roughing call on Barmore. Sympathy penalty... I can't stand those!
 
It Takes Eleven said:
Good - We won it, Waddle was a factor and Dickerson got on the field. It got a little dusty there...
Bad - We're a hit or miss team - on average, just six out of twelve...
Ugly - hated the injuries, hopeful they all heal easily and fully.

Love you guys, Roll Tide.
Click to expand...
giphy.gif
 

Similar threads

alabama mike
🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs. Indiana
5 6 7
Replies
129
Views
2K
Rolltide24
R
alabama mike
🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs. AweBarn?
2 3 4
Replies
63
Views
2K
BamaFan334
BamaFan334
alabama mike
🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs. E. Illinois
2 3
Replies
46
Views
1K
rick4bama
rick4bama
alabama mike
🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs. Oklahoma
5 6 7
Replies
130
Views
3K
shipley00
shipley00
alabama mike
🏈 The Good, The Bad and The Ugly vs. LSU
3 4 5
Replies
94
Views
2K
UAgrad93
UAgrad93
Back
Top Bottom