McElroy is about the same kind of QB as JPW, not a great fit for this ssystem, but not terrible in it. Considering JPW returning as a senior QB/(2 year starter, Fanuzzi being a more athletic QB than Mac, and Star Jackson arriving in the fall, he may be seeing that the competition for PT is going to be pretty intense next year, and he likely would not play much more than this. The question he, and others in his situation, will have to decide whether it is worth it to transfer and lose a year's eligibility, leaving only two years to play.