Thanks for the sensibility in a mad world.
If we lose to ULM in year 3, Saban will be the one to blame... he clearly is not to blame in year 1.
I don't pretend to know the daily goings-ons in T-town, but I do faithfully attend the games. There is a noticeable difference in the players that "do it right" and the ones that don't. You can tell the ones that give 100% and the ones that go through the motions.
Watch which linebackers make the correct reads and take the right angles. Watch which DB's sacrifice themselves to make a first-down-saving tackle. Watch which linemen run downfield to make the extra block. Watch which receiver runs his route full speed, even when he isn't the primary receiver.
When your "leaders" are the ones going through the motions, your chances of success are greatly reduced.