| FTBL College football coaches' association to propose transfer windows

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- College football coaches will propose transfer windows in the late fall and spring to help with roster management around the transfer portal.

Todd Berry, executive director of the American Football Coaches Association, said Tuesday his group would like two transfer windows for players to enter their names in the portal: one from the final Sunday in November until the early signing date in mid-December, and another from April 15 to May 1. Both windows would coincide with contact periods in recruiting. Players wouldn't be required to transfer, only to enter the portal during designated time periods.

The NCAA's transfer portal, which debuted in October 2018, currently doesn't have specific windows for movement. The only deadline is that players must notify schools that they are entering the portal by May 1 of each academic year. Berry noted that AFCA members proposed transfer windows before the portal went into effect, but they have not been adopted.

"We knew there were going to be very few controls over it, but at least if we had a window, then the student-athletes would be able to go, 'Is this a good decision? Because here's my competition. Now I know what the other competition is because we're all in the window at the same time,'" Berry told ESPN. "It might change some perspectives. They need to be able to make educated decisions.

"We're working on a window concept that I think is going to be very good for the student-athlete, to give them those opportunities, and to provide the universities and their team and teammates with a little bit more clarity on positions and recruiting and those kinds of things."

Berry said the current portal setup without windows has created "turmoil" and "chaos" with roster management. He thinks the coaches' proposal likely will go to the NCAA Division I football oversight committee and the Division I transformation committee. A football oversight committee source told ESPN that transfer windows are a "foregone conclusion."

Arizona coach Jedd Fisch said multiple transfer windows are important to help both athletes and coaches.


"There are two legitimate windows: after the season and after spring [practice]," Fisch told ESPN. "To assume that they can make a decision after just a season, you're assuming that recruiting isn't going to play a role. You have to see who did they sign, what did the recruiting class look like and then spring ball, who came early. 'I thought I was the second back but I'm really the fourth back.' Who left early?

"You have to give them that opportunity."

Berry said the AFCA also supports eliminating the maximum of 25 initial scholarships coaches are allowed during each recruiting class, saying that teams should be allowed to reach the 85-scholarship limit on their own timetable. Berry mentioned one school that has as few as 62 total scholarship players, and "with all the chaos," some teams have so many holes to fill on their roster they don't have enough players at certain positions.

By keeping the number of annual official visits at 56, teams would be prevented from overturning their entire rosters.

"We need to lose [25 initial scholarships per year] and we need to create some portal windows and then we need to build a recruiting calendar that understands that some of it's going to be high school and some of it's going to be transfers," Berry said. "And you got two transfer windows to work around. And so it's going to take a reworking of the calendar, but we need to find out first if we can get the portal windows put in."

 

TerryP

Misomaniac
Ivory Club
If the coaches agree to only leave jobs in that same window, I’m good.
Because their situations are so comparable. Unless you're suggesting players become University employees?

Three proposals on the windows: all of them are approximately two weeks.

Three conferences submitted proposals. I don't know which proposal came from which conference but here's a brief breakdown.

1) Somewhere in mid-January up until the first Wednesday of February.
2) After spring camps: middle of April until early May.
3) After the last regular season game up until the December signing period.
 

It Takes Eleven

Quoth the Raven...
Scholarship Club
Because their situations are so comparable. Unless you're suggesting players become University employees?

Three proposals on the windows: all of them are approximately two weeks.

Three conferences submitted proposals. I don't know which proposal came from which conference but here's a brief breakdown.

1) Somewhere in mid-January up until the first Wednesday of February.
2) After spring camps: middle of April until early May.
3) After the last regular season game up until the December signing period.

I'm saying it's a self-serving proposal, "help make our jobs easier by limiting others' opportunities". Leave in mid-December ahead of bowl season or you miss out on your new team's spring practice.

This is not going backwards. The NIL brake-check the NCAA put out means nothing. This is Talladega/Daytona, flatfooting around the track. If you lift up, you're done. Not sure where it ends, other than with "the big one".
 

TerryP

Misomaniac
Ivory Club
I'm saying it's a self-serving proposal, "help make our jobs easier by limiting others' opportunities". Leave in mid-December ahead of bowl season or you miss out on your new team's spring practice.
Their jobs are impossible right now. That's why we're seeing teams with rosters sizes in the 60's. Not everyone can negotiate roster management like we're used to seeing at Bama.

That's not a level playing field for many schools even if it's a PAC, Stanford squad, competing with USC.
 

It Takes Eleven

Quoth the Raven...
Scholarship Club
Their jobs are impossible right now. That's why we're seeing teams with rosters sizes in the 60's. Not everyone can negotiate roster management like we're used to seeing at Bama.

That's not a level playing field for many schools even if it's a PAC, Stanford squad, competing with USC.
I'm not a fan.

But, you either adjust and manage, or you lag. What's Vandy doing in the SEC? Is Clemson as tone deaf as the peanut gallery says? Things are moving quickly.
 
Top Bottom