Why the quotation marks over spreadsheet? That's what it was; an Excel spread sheet.
Participate that much? An email is "that much?" How is it any different than a head coach talking to other head coaches about assistant hires?
The sheet is so simple in its methodology I don't see what the big deal is in the first place.
Hello John,
My name is Kyle Vasey and I am an assistant AD for strategic planning at Alabama. Greg Byrne asked me to send you some analysis we performed on head coaches recently. Youāll find an excel spreadsheet which ranks head coaches based on a metric we created called: coaching efficiency. This metric is a weighted score which incorporates various factors such as national championships, final AP ranking, overall win percentage, etc. Youāll also find a pdf file which analyzes coaches based on their previous coaching experience: Power 5 Head Coach, Power 5 Assistant Coach, former NFL head coach, etc
I am happy to answer any questions you might have on the data.
Thanks,
Kyle Vasey
"The ratings used a weighting system that tied 40 percent of a rating to national championship seasons, 30 percent to AP Poll top-10 finishes, 20 percent to winning percentage, and 10 percent to ārecency factor,ā or five-year success." It's not that complicated--a comparison chart a kid in junior high could have put together.
I'm reminded of a statement the AD at Mizzou or A&M made when they attended their first SEC meeting(s.) It was along the lines of how well the AD's from different schools within the SEC worked together versus what they'd been exposed to coming from the Big 12. The gist of the statement was "they were working together for the betterment of the conference, not for pushing their school or agenda above the others." (We've seen the later on several occasions.)
I see much ado about nothing.