ExiledTidefan said:
I am here to tell you that Mike Shula took a beating from a large majority of Bama fans. He was raked over the coals. I'm sure I can honestly say that we are better off today, but he should get nothing but a "thank you" and a pat on the back as he left Tuscaloosa. He's a fine person, a good football coach, and a pretty good judge of talent. Probably just lacks the skills to run the organization. It's common in big time coaching, pro or otherwise.
As I said, I thought Shula was class in his interview - but lets not play revisionist history with his firing. I am not going to beat the dead horse anymore, but Shula's #1 problem was his own stubbornness. It wasn't organizational skills or managerial ability. He knew what needed to be done and refused to do it. He had no trouble firing people, but someone who does not hesitate to fire Ben Pollard - arguably the best S&C coach in America, and refuses to let arguably the worst OL coach in America go, made his own bed. He should have made himself QB coach, and hired a real OC. When Mal asked Mike for a plan to turn things around following the 2006 season, the bulk of what he had to do was:
(1) Replace Bob "Bucket Step" Connelly
(2) Replace Dave Rader with quality playcalling OC.
(3) demote self to QB's
...and address recruiting deficiencies.
The defense was fine.
He was to present his plan to Moore Sunday night after the Iron Bowl. Mal called him at the office, then at home, then on his cell - and got no answer. Finally, Coach Moore drove to Shula's house and found him there.
What Mike offered was:
(1) Turn over playcalling to Rader
(2) reassign Dave Ungerer to assist Connelly with OL.
That was it. I believed then, as I do now, that Shula wanted to be fired. That is the only explanation for his behavior surrounding the events after the Iron Bowl in 2006.
So while I do think Mike is a class guy and I do wish him success - I also think he could have kept his job and had success. He made his own bed.