🏈 Randle v. Kirkpatrick

[Duder]

Anyone else excited to see that match-up?

 

[bamatommy]

Randle concerns me greatly. Bama tried hard to get him, and I can see why. He is NFL-caliber.

 

[Hoos4Tide]

If we put Kirkpatrick on Randle I'd be very surprised... I don't know what everyone thinks or what has been shown on the field but is Dequan Menzie not head and shoulders better than Kirkpatrick???

 

[TerryP]

That's not the game plan Duder...

 

[Southern Bama]

That's not the game plan Duder...

Thats right......randle will get his jock sabatoged with Icy Hot. :lol:

 

[JoshB]

Menzie vs. Randle? hmmm I think I would rather Dre head up with him, Dre's more physical and I think you gotta get physical with him. But that's why Saban is the coach.

Lets whoop Tennessee asses this week first tho. :hyper:

 

[bamatommy]

Thats right......randle will get his jock sabatoged with Icy Hot. :lol:

:lol:

 

[Duder]

That's not the game plan Duder...

I'm not saying he will shadow him for 60 minutes but at some point he will guard him and it is intriguing. I think it is a much better match-up from a size and physicality standpoint.

 

[Alabama12fan64]

Ask NFL scouts whos better Kirkpatrick or Menzie... I dont think any would say Menzie.
NFL personel love Kirkpatrick.

 

[BamaFan615]

Ask NFL scouts whos better Kirkpatrick or Menzie... I dont think any would say Menzie.
NFL personel love Kirkpatrick.

I remember people having this argument a few years ago with Javy and Kareem Jackson. Kirkpatrick's biggest weakness has been his slender build, but he sure has been lighting people up this year When it comes time for the NFL draft, I see a lot of scouts comparing Dre to Antonio Cromartie.

 

[Hoos4Tide]

Ask NFL scouts whos better Kirkpatrick or Menzie... I dont think any would say Menzie.
NFL personel love Kirkpatrick.

Yeah, I do know that, the two goofballs on ESPN love him too but I just don't get that, Menzie's stats are just better, plain and simple, Menzie is more effective than Dre... but of course, honestly, what do I know...

 

[TideAlum05]

Man I think Dre is our best cover guy, but like you said, what do I know. I thought he was way overrated before this season, but he's playing super physical.

 

[Alabama12fan64]

Anytime you.get a physical corner who can cover you go high in the draft. Dre fits the bill.

 

[4th-and-1]

I think upshaw and hightower will
be our best defense against randall.

 

[JoshB]

Yeah, I do know that, the two goofballs on ESPN love him too but I just don't get that, Menzie's stats are just better, plain and simple, Menzie is more effective than Dre... but of course, honestly, what do I know...

Ever thought Menzie's 'stats' might be better because Dre doesnt get thrown at much?