Alright let me weigh in a bit...
LSU fans feel "wronged" because of a few reasons. First off I want to repeat that Saban built the foundation LSU and Miles currently stand on. No one in their right mind hates Saban for what he did while at LSU, in fact we respect his ability. Also, no sane LSU fan will deny that he will turn the Bama program around. With that said...as a student/fan of LSU I feel that Saban basically quit on his LSU team in 2004. He said he wont comment on a possible NFL job for months and then days before the Capital One bowl admitted he was leaving. That team had lots of talent, but was young and needed a strong leader and I think Saban basically quit on his team and the university. I had no problem with him taking an NFL job, its just the fact that he couldnt tell us and then he quit on us midseason.
He is also disliked becasue of his return to the SEC. It isnt because we are irrational. Anytime your coach leaves for a rival, it becomes fun to want to beat that coach, whether he was loved or hated. The manner in which he left Miami was somewhat disgraceful. I thought it to be a shame that he left those players without addressing the team and after claiming he "will not be the coach at Alabama." While this does not impact LSU directly, it was unethical and it only fuels the desire to beat him.
Lastly, and my personal main reason to want to beat Saban. Coach Miles is very disrespected among SEC coaches. Please note that the pass to Auburn was not a gamble. If time had expired for some reason then the play would have been reviewed and 4 seconds would have been put on the clock...check the replay. Coach Miles has done a magnificent job here at LSU regardless of whose players he has. You are correct that recruiting is easier when you're good, but this has nothing to do with Miles. We love the fact that hes honest and intense. The players love him and the man has lost 5 games in 2 and a half years. We really like Coach Miles and think he is superior to Saban because when it comes down to it, his record is better and thats the only number that matters in the long run. Time will tell to see if he can get a championship under his belt. We hate the talk of Miles being dumb because LSU is better than any team's fans that say that.
With that said I do see your point that this may be dumb, but it is what it is and as an LSU fan i cannot wait until saturday