If he doesn't want to be at bama, and it was anywhere close to obvious, Saban would have asked him to move on out the door. It wouldn't have come down to keeping him around if his heart isn't in it, and I questioned that some this past season. I almost had myself convinced that he had already been promised a head coaching gig somewhere, and he was just mentally cashing it in at times, ala Dennis Franchione 2002 versus Auburn.
I'm not comparing McElwain in any other way to Franchione. Not even close. I don't have a problem with some of our offensive gameplans, just the playcalling at times was nonsensical.
But the real story as to why things didn't work out for us in 2010 was player EXECUTION. Blame the guys wearing the jerseys if you want to blame anyone at all.