I've eaten it a few times and, like you, experience has varied. Caught it so figured I'd try cooking it.Never done that. I've eaten it several times. Poogan's here in town. OH MAN! That was good. There's a place about three miles from here that also serves it...meh. The food was ok, the prices weren't. For god's sake, they took a Sears Tire place and turned it into a restaurant...can't get that out of my head. There's another place called "Uncork Charleston" ... that was good. Their Whipped Goat Cheese Crostini...make you slap someone.