Not only is the statute of limitations LONG passed but it would be their word (people no one has ever heard of) against the players word with absolutely no evidence. So, either this story is bullshit or its a combination of the players being smart and these guys doing the buying being very dumb considering it was supposedly all done with cash and conversations in person.
Well, one of the guys is in prison for 6 years for fraud. Selling fake autographed memorabilia.