šŸˆ Phil Marshall--development is overblown in college football. It's not that important and doesn't happen often.

Max

Member
-- The whole "Gus Malzahn can't develop quarterbacks" thing has taken on a life of its own. Malzahn is not the QB coach. Chip Lindsey is. Teaching is clearly important, but all coaches get too much credit for so-called "developing." I think a lot more first-round draft picks at every position are recruited than are "developed." If not, Alabama has failed to develop several quarterbacks. I tend to give players more credit for what they do than their coaches. Dee Ford went from being an undersized defensive end to being a first-round. draft pick because of his relentless work ethic, not because of some secret some coach taught him. To say Nick Marshall was ready-made after he threw 20 interceptions in junior college and played DB the year before that doesn't make sense to me.

-- Jarrett Stidham, it seems, no longer gets credit for passing for more than 3,000 yards and taking his team to a 7-1 SEC record and two wins over No. 1 teams. But if he did, it seems the credit would go to Art Briles for coaching him for less than a year. It's really hard for me to figure why, in this year in particular, this whole thing would suddenly become a popular narrative anyway. Because Stidham has had some struggles with a new OL and new running backs, I guess.

-- Australian punter Arryn Siposs is more than living up to his billing. He’s averaging 45.3 yards per punt which is outstanding. Even better is that Auburn is second in the SEC in net punting at 43.1 yards.

-- Track stars who double as football players normally have to essentially learn how to play the game when they get to college. Not so with Auburn freshman Anthony Schwartz. He might the fastest player in college football, but he’s also a very good route-runner with very good hands. And he is a tough, hard-nosed young man on top of that.

-- For much of the offseason, the talk was about the difficulty of Notre Dame’s schedule. It was the same old story. The reality is this. Notre Dame has one win over a nationally ranked team (Michigan). It plays another one Saturday (Stanford). And that’s it. Notre Dame doesn’t play another team in the current rankings. I know a lot of SEC teams that would love to have schedule like that.

-- Speaking of schedules, Clemson doesn’t have a win over a team in the current poll, and plays just one. That’s No. 22 Duke at home on Nov. 17.

-- Kentucky was fined $100,000 by the SEC because fans stormed the field after last Saturday’s 28-7 win over Mississippi State. I wonder when was the last time fans stormed the field to celebrate beating Mississippi State. Never?

-- It’s a different day in college football. The graduate transfer rule and now the redshirt rule have made it much easier for players to move between programs late in their careers. They are taking advantage of it, and so are the programs that need their services. Kelly Bryant will probably be somebody’s starting quarterback next season. So will Jalen Hurts. Alabama won a national championship with Jake Coker, a graduate transfer quarterback. Where coaches once looked at junior colleges to fill immediate needs, they now have a much larger pool of players who have actually proved they can compete and win at the highest level.

-- I don't believe ever, in all my years, I have seen such angst about a 34-3 victory as I have in the past several days.
 
If a player improves from the time they step on campus to the time they leave they have experienced ā€œdevelopmentā€. If players are gonna develop on their own thru ā€œhard workā€... there’s really no need for multiple coaches. Just let them work hard all week and turn them loose on game day.
 
@scottyhk, He's talking out of his butt again, Scotty. In the same thought he's saying Marshall was developed when he arrived at Auburn because he wasn't before he got there (DB and the INT numbers.) But, there's no development?

It's been documented where Bama has a far higher success rate with blue-chip players being drafted than any other program in FBS football. But, there's no development.
 
Many high school players do not need a ton of teaching or " development ". While many others do not have what it takes inside, the
"want to attitude" or heart or have what it takes between the ears. Great coaches can help develop , teach and inspire high school players to be good or great college players regardless of star ranking.
 
Here is why people say GUSSY can't develop players or QBs...

Auburn Backup QBs in a blowout victory vs Alabama State (63-3) play the entire 2nd half with stats of....
2 completions on 3 attempts.
Handoffs to the RB - 30+

He had the perfect opportunity to put his backup QB in the game with the starting lineup and develop some timing/chemistry with the WR in a live game situation in case he has to call on his backup later on down the schedule... but he completely fails to do that and instead uses them as a hand off tool to fill space. Waste of development opportunity is why he sucks so much. Well, that and his play calling ;)

What PM fails to understand is development isn't just showing them what to do, but giving the the opportunities to learn it... along with the motivation to WANT to learn it. Auburn has the tendency to "worship" their players and soft hand the players. This is why the majority of the time they can't or don't develop players. They neither put the players into position to develop nor do they motivate them to develop.
 
Last edited:
I'm surprised that Marshall can see the page to write with Malzahn's goober in his mouth. Talk about drinking the kool-aid.

I know I'm biased, but we truly are spoiled to have Cecil Hurt covering Alabama. I remember Cecil writing during the Shula years, and always attempted to be fair and give the benefit of the doubt during those probation years. After the Miss St loss in 2006, he called into question Shula and his coaching style, staff, and the fact that he has been there long enough to do better than what we were seeing on the field. I was at that game and I think Shula's fate was determined long before the final seconds of the clock counted down. I sat in my seat with me feet propped up on the seat in front of me the entire game, because the folks that normally sit there, never showed. I leaned back on the seat behind me with my elbows propped up, because the people that normally sit there, never showed up. The student section (which was smaller at the time) was half empty (full) by half time, of a "close/winnable" game. While I'm sure Shula's fate had already been determined......when Cecil starts questioning you openly from his keyboard...........you gone!
 
What PM fails to understand is development isn't just showing them what to do, but giving the the opportunities to learn it... along with the motivation to WANT to learn it. Auburn has the tendency to "worship" their players and soft hand the players. This is why the majority of the time they can't or don't develop players. They neither put the players into position to develop nor do they motivate them to develop.

I'd say rather than Butterteeth fails to understand is more like Butterteeth stays in denial of...
 
Back
Top Bottom