I read this yesterday on the Reddit RollTide board:
Let's Talk About...Offensive Line
# 2021 Review
I refuse to start by dumping on a 13-2 team, so let me preface with this: 2021 was a fun year. For much of the season Bama really struggled to close out games and played a number of teams much closer than they should have. Then against Auburn, with their backs against the wall the team had to grow up all at once. But they believed in themselves, played with pride and dedication, never quit, and fought their way to a 4OT win in (what was, up until just recently) the Jordan-Hare House of Horrors. And the most beautiful part of the season was how they applied the same principles in Atlanta: finding themselves down 10-0 to the #1 team in the country, Bama never blinked, surging back to win by three scores and ultimately earn a National Championship Game berth. There, beaten and battered, they came up a quarter short of number 19, but through it all, they showed their class and never quit.
Now, about the offensive line…
It was bad. Bad enough to make Ears Whitworth wince.
Run blocking they managed a paltry 4.11 YPC—the lowest since Bama barely topped 4.0 in 2007. Failing to top 100 yards on the ground against Florida set off early warning bells. Then against LSU, the run game effectively disappeared, with 26 attempts managing a mere six yards against a team bad enough that they were already looking for a new coach. At Auburn, the line struggled once again, before producing a shockingly strong performance against Georgia. Unfortunately, in Indianapolis, the Bulldogs’ defensive line reasserted itself to hold Bama to barely one yard per carry.
Pass blocking they played even worse, giving up 41 sacks—the worst since a school record 43 in 1996. If giving up four sacks apiece to Texas A&M and LSU revealed a serious problem, then Arkansas teeing off for four more should’ve set off some sort of emergency alarm. Auburn alone took Bryce Young to the turf seven times, in what felt like the worst single-game offensive line performance since 2005’s infamous “Honk If You Sacked Brodie” Iron Bowl. Georgia’s tactically questionable decision to eschew the blitz seemed an important factor in Atlanta, but they corrected the mistake in racking up four sacks in Indianapolis. That Bryce Young managed to overcome such a deficiency to win a Heisman Trophy and lead the team to a 13-2 record remains remarkable.
# 2021 Analysis
How did it happen? Though Bama has recruited well along the offensive line (according to the rankings, at least), it became apparent that none of the young tackles were remotely ready for primetime. Then a preseason injury to Kendall Randolph effectively sent Bama into the season without a right tackle. Super-senior Chris Owens was thus pressed into duty outside, and unfortunately played exactly like a man forced out of his natural playing position. Later in the season, injuries sent Owens back to center for a spell. This revealed that the alternative was even worse, as Damieon George, though powerful, looked hopelessly lost as the unit reached its nadir in the first half against Auburn. With Owens back outside, the entire unit looked better down the stretch, but lacking a true right tackle proved a season-long weakness.
Additionally, the unit clearly struggled with replacing Landon Dickerson at center. Communication seemed poor for the majority of the season, with even Coach Saban noting it as a deficiency in College Station. However, later in the season, it seemed to improve with Seth McLaughlin taking over in the middle.
Ultimately, poor communication and lack of player development tend to point blame in one primary direction. After spending nearly a decade wearing out his welcome as an NFL head coach, Doug Marrone returned to college football as an offensive line coach and performed as though he should have returned as a graduate assistant. That his arrival heralded one of the worst seasons of offensive line play in school history does not appear to have been overlooked, as he immediately departed for the NFL where he may well heap new miseries on unsuspecting fan bases.
# Position Losses
In terms of graduates, most notably we lose permanent team captain LT
Evan Neal, a three-year starter at guard and tackle, and super senior RT
Chris Owens, who spent most of his career as a reserve, but crucially stepped in for injured Landon Dickerson to close out 2020.
Meanwhile reserves
Tommy Brown and
Pierce Quick have portalled away in search of playing time, and incoming freshman tackle
Dayne Shor has departed via portal practically before he ever arrived.
# 2022 Preview
With Marrone out, Eric Wolford has arrived as the new offensive line coach. A veteran line coach, Wolford appears primed for success. After serving on Muschamp’s staff at South Carolina, he comes off a one-year stint at Kentucky that saw his unit named a finalist for the Joe Moore Award. At Alabama, he will undoubtedly have more raw talent to work with than at any other point in his college coaching career.
With a new boss, change is sure to come, but certain parts of the starting line still seem obvious:
Right Guard
First, it seems certain that veteran
Emil Ekiyor will again start at right guard. Though out for the spring recovering from injury, he is the only remaining member of 2020’s road graders and played well in 2021.
Left Guard
Second, at
l**eft guard, it seems likely that **Javion Cohen will reprise his role. Praised for his developing leadership, there was some talk from the media that he might get a look at tackle, but there was little sign of this in the spring. With both tackle spots now open and one proving an outright disaster in 2021, it seems likely he’d have gotten a significant look outside by now if it was a serious possibility.
Center
At center, a position battle is likely.
Darrian Dalcourt won the job last year, but struggled to stay healthy even as communication proved a severe challenge for the line. In his absence, Chris Owens returned to center, but by the second half of the Iron Bowl, a desperate coaching staff gave redshirt freshman
Seth McLaughlin a shot. Though rated three stars by Rivals and 247, McLaughlin was a member of 2020’s ESPN 300. ESPN’s evaluation proved more accurate as McLaughlin’s play helped stabilize the line over the last three and a half games of the season. With Dalcourt out for the spring, McLaughlin maintained his role as starting center through A-Day. Now as Dalcourt returns, the two seem set to clash for the job. In my opinion, the line’s improved play at the end of 2021 coupled with McLaughlin’s reps in the spring under a new position coach give him the inside track. Dalcourt could well get Wally Pipped here.
Right Tackle
Unfortunately, with Evan Neal turning pro, Alabama must now find two new starting tackles after struggling at right tackle a season ago. However, one spot seems set.
JC Latham, a former IMG Academy graduate like Neal, spent all spring with the first team at right tackle. A highly-touted 2020 recruit, he seems almost certain to start at one tackle spot. However several options are possible on the other side.
Left Tackle
In the spring, super senior
Kendall Randolph spent the most time opposite Latham at left tackle.
Amari Kight and
Tommy Brockermeyer received opportunities as well, though neither seemed particularly impressive. However the most promising possibility opposite Latham is Vanderbilt transfer
Tyler Steen. Originally a defensive lineman for the Commodores, Steen became a three year starter at tackle, with the last two on the left side. If he can step in and play at a high level, the line looks primed for success. However, though Steen was sought as a transfer by LSU and others, the fact remains that his performance at Vandy could best be described as “solid.” As a high school recruit, his potential was rated far below that of his competition.
Randolph has been praised by Coach Saban for his leadership and will certainly get a shot to win the job, but Steen’s experience gives him a clear edge. If Steen struggles, Randolph is the mostly likely to claim this spot, though he was far from locking up the position in the spring. Randolph has spent years as a blocking tight end (and is
still listed at TE/OL on the 2022 roster), and is somewhat shorter and lighter than Steen and others. One dark horse could be
Tyler Booker, a true freshman who worked his way into the two deep in the spring. If other candidates struggle, he could continue climbing the depth chart.
In my opinion, Steen may be the most important player to watch in fall camp. If he can play well enough to seize the left tackle spot outright, the line could be dominant once again. However, should he struggle, Randolph presents limited upside. His performance in spring suggests that “solid” is likely his ceiling. If Booker or another youngster outperform both, anything is possible, including Latham switching to the more important left side.
Reserves
In addition to those who lose the above-referenced position battles, the second team will likely include powerful
Damieon George, who has shifted inside to guard after his experience at tackle last season, and
Terrence Ferguson, who also saw time at guard in the spring. Our other returning scholarship players include
Tanner Bowles and
James Brockermeyer, competing principally for third-string center, and
Jaeden Roberts, a redshirt freshman guard. This fall, tackle recruit
Elijah Pritchett will join Booker as the unit’s freshman class. Booker’s early enrollment and time at IMG Academy make him the most likely to contribute early.
# A-Day Performance
To address a popular concern, A-Day was indeed an outright disaster for the unit, with the defenses combining for an absurd fifteen sacks. However, the game’s format, the unit’s competition from what projects as a truly legendary pass rush, and the absence of Ekiyor, Dalcourt, and incoming transfer Steen suggest that patience rather than panic is the most reasonable response.
# Conclusion
In summary,
my best projection at a starting lineup is, left to right, Tyler Steen-Javion Cohen-Seth McLaughlin-Emil Ekiyor-JC Latham, with Kendall Randolph, Dameion George, and Darrian Dalcourt serving as key reserves at tackle, guard, and center, respectively. I don’t expect an all-time performance, though I do very much expect a return to the Saban-era standard for the position group. However, with a great deal of talent and experience likely to return, 2023’s unit could be particularly good.
# Additional Reading
Chris Walsh at Bama Central (SI)
Nick Kelly at Tuscaloosa News
Stacey Blackwood at RollTideWire (USA Today)
CB969 at RollBamaRoll
Michael Casagrande at AL.com