| FTBL If we had a Plus One BCS Playoff

[BamaHubMan]

Bama would play Ok and Tx would play FL.

Winners meet week later.

USC be complaining

If we had 8 team play off. Boise State would be complaining, they are 12-0.

Ohio State has 2 losses and would not have much ground.

Does the 8 team Play offs bring much resolution to who is No 1 or is the Plus one good enough to bring true No. 1? Just looking at this years example.


Plus one we would have a lot of excitement in Bama Florida rematch for NC. Tx and Ok rematch would bring about a lot of interest also.

 

[reger60]

Bama would play Ok and Tx would play FL.

Winners meet week later.

USC be complaining

If we had 8 team play off. Boise State would be complaining, they are 12-0.

Ohio State has 2 losses and would not have much ground.

Does the 8 team Play offs bring much resolution to who is No 1 or is the Plus one good enough to bring true No. 1? Just looking at this years example.


Plus one we would have a lot of excitement in Bama Florida rematch for NC.

I honestly think that this year's Orange Bowl is going to determine a true number one.

 

[billfish]

Bama would play Ok and Tx would play FL.

Winners meet week later.

USC be complaining

If we had 8 team play off. Boise State would be complaining, they are 12-0.

Ohio State has 2 losses and would not have much ground.

Does the 8 team Play offs bring much resolution to who is No 1 or is the Plus one good enough to bring true No. 1? Just looking at this years example.


Plus one we would have a lot of excitement in Bama Florida rematch for NC. Tx and Ok rematch would bring about a lot of interest also.

Isn't this what Mike Slive/SEC suggested for "playoff"?

To some it makes sense and money.....wait? Does that qualify for oxymoron status? :lol:

 

[imported_RollTideRandy]

I honestly think that this year's Orange Bowl is going to determine a true number one.

You think Va Tech and Cincinnati are playing that well right now?

 

[CrimsonPirate]

Is that a Plus One? Sounds like a Top 4 playoff. I thought a Plus One was where the bowl games were played, complete with tie-ins, and then the top two teams would be selected via the BCS system. In other words, bowl games plus one.

 

[reger60]

I honestly think that this year's Orange Bowl is going to determine a true number one.

You think Va Tech and Cincinnati are playing that well right now?

Aw, crap. You knew what I meant.

 

[BamaHubMan]

Is that a Plus One? Sounds like a Top 4 playoff. I thought a Plus One was where the bowl games were played, complete with tie-ins, and then the top two teams would be selected via the BCS system. In other words, bowl games plus one.

This is what I remember Saban pushing as a plus one. Get the top 4 teams play in two bowl games. Then have the winners play in a NC game that was not a bowl game (IE NCAA gets the money) a week later. Bowl system in tack. One additional game for 2 teams. Extends season 1 week. I might have not heard correctly.

 

[BAMAFSTBACK]

We had our shot. No complaining out of me this year.

 

[Kirk Van de Graaff]

We had our shot. No complaining out of me this year.

I am right there with ya. This has been a great season, I am real proud of our team.

 

[Guest]

We had our shot. No complaining out of me this year.

I am right there with ya. This has been a great season, I am real proud of our team.

No doubt, 100% agree. A plus one would of made things interesting though.

 

[BamaHubMan]

We had our shot. No complaining out of me this year.

Please don't get me wrong. I am not complaining. I am just wondering how a Plus one might play out and if that would be fair. Just trying to get discussion going.