I understand the crush of UGA applicants has made it much harder to get in, but is it a downside for lower income students to be able to afford college? I think a bigger story is the boost to second and third tier schools in the state. With HOPE, many qualified students stay in state.
If Alabama had the lottery - and applied the proceeds similarly as Georgia - it would soften the blow to both Alabama and Auburn when an inevitable decline in out-of-state attendance occurs. Georgia lottery profits, after all commissions and payouts, contributed $1.5 billion last year to HOPE and pre-K, which was a record. For frame of reference, the 1997 contribution was about $580 million, probably in the ballpark of what Alabama might realize.