| FTBL Does McFadden have a legitimate shot at the heisman?

[BigAl]

What do you guys and gals think? I hope he does but they gonna find someway to screw him out of it by thats jmo.

 

[imported_Porter]

I would hope so, but I don't have a vote. He is right there with Bo and Herschel as the best SEC RB's ever. He put on the clinic of clinics last night against SC.

 

[Argo]

If D-Mac doesn't = Heisman

Heisman doesn't = Best college player

 

[Proud Tiger]

He should get it IMHO. I don't know who is any better qualified. He is certanly in there with Hershel and Bo as the best I have ever seen. Shaun Alexander wasn't shabby either.

 

[bamadezz]

If that cat doesn't get it somethings way wrong! He's like a train coming at ya!

 

[CrimsonPirate]

Fellas, D-Mac isn't a QB, nor does he play for Southern Cal, Notre Dame, or a Big10 team. He's doubly cursed. :shock:

 

[HiTide]

Heisman doesn't = Best college player

Unfortunately we already know that is the case. Guys like Gino proved that long ago.

 

[bamadam]

Fellas, D-Mac isn't a QB, nor does he play for Southern Cal, Notre Dame, or a Big10 team. He's doubly cursed. :shock:

Ahh you beat me to it.

 

[Bamapossum]

If Arkansas had been more successful this year, it would have been probable, but I don't think so anymore. Arky has simply had too many losses.

While I think McFadden may be the best back in a while, he is NO Hershel Walker. Hershel Walker was literally able to put the UGA team on his back and win a MNC. If McFadden had been able to tote Arkansas to even a SEC West title this season, he might have won, but I don't think it is to be. They started 0-3 in the SEC and still have LSU to lose to.

 

[imported_porkchop]

If it were actually about the best player then yes. But the Heisman is not about the best player so I doubt it.

Arkansas has lost too many games for the "experts" to award McFadden the Heisman. You see, somehow in the grand scheme of things (probably when the media got involved) it went from being the best player to being the best player on the winningest team. The whole thing is an excersise in <BS> . It's a popularity contest at best. The best players rarely win the award.

 

[Guest]

If I had to pick a current favorite player outside of Alabama's, D-Mac would be my first choice.

The guy deserves the heisman no matter what Arkansas' record is this season. I usually don't care about who wins the heisman, but with a special player like D-Mac...you just can't ignore him.

 

[Argo]

Maybe someone should start a "People's Heisman Trophy" award.

 

[Guest]

Maybe someone should start a "People's Heisman Trophy" award.

Not a bad idea actually. Should start a website and maybe it will pick up. :shock:

 

[JoshB]

naw i dont think so. Arkansas & McFadden get little to no attention from the media and they lose to much. imo hes by far the best back in the nation but i doubt he'll get it.

 

[Guest]

The B.C. QB will get it. Everytime I watch TV all I hear about is B.C. or now it's Kansas :lol: