| FTBL Do you think JPW is the best QB this decade?

[Guest]

One of my fellow soldiers ask me this question. What do you think?

 

[Guest]

I think he's a good QB, but I'd have to go with Brodie on this one. If Brodie were QB now behind this offensive line...we would be destroying teams left and right in not just our running game, but the passing game.

 

[bama4life]

I think he's a good QB, but I'd have to go with Brodie on this one. If Brodie were QB now behind this offensive line...we would be destroying teams left and right in not just our running game, but the passing game.

I will agree with this as well. If Brodie also stayed healthy, I don't JP would have passed him on some of the stats.

 

[JCinBAMA]

Hes 17-13 as a starter

 

[shipley00]

I think he's a good QB, but I'd have to go with Brodie on this one. If Brodie were QB now behind this offensive line...we would be destroying teams left and right in not just our running game, but the passing game.

Ditto.

 

[It Takes Eleven]

I think he's a good QB, but I'd have to go with Brodie on this one. If Brodie were QB now behind this offensive line...we would be destroying teams left and right in not just our running game, but the passing game.

Ditto.

Brodie probably wishes he had our line with him in Kansas City.

 

[Guest]

Brodie for sure. Nothing against JPW, but he doesn't have anything like Brodie's arm. He's got an NFL-caliber cannon, and that's that. His arm probably would have been good for 3 or 4 more TD's at least.

 

[Guest]

Brodie for sure. Nothing against JPW, but he doesn't have anything like Brodie's arm. He's got an NFL-caliber cannon, and that's that. His arm probably would have been good for 3 or 4 more TD's at least.

3 or 4 so far this season I mean.

 

[JoshB]

easily Brodie Croyle. he only really had one full season as a starter. had he not been injured in '04 then JP would prolly not be anywhere near Brodie's numbers. i have no problem with JP and i think hes a very talented QB but just not the QB that Brodie was/is.

 

[JoshB]

I think he's a good QB, but I'd have to go with Brodie on this one. If Brodie were QB now behind this offensive line...we would be destroying teams left and right in not just our running game, but the passing game.

Ditto.

Brodie probably wishes he had our line with him in Kansas City.

Brodie also wishes he had this line in '05 too, National Title would've been ours had he had the time he should've that year (and especially had Prothro not gotten hurt but thats another discussion). Brodie was runnin for his life this year (before he got hurt) like he was in '05.

 

[Guest]

uh, no

 

[Red_Tsunami]

For now I'm going with Tyler Watts. He was a winner. Brodie was overrated and JPW still has the rest of this year to prove himself.

 

[Billie Bob]

For now I'm going with Tyler Watts. He was a winner. Brodie was overrated and JPW still has the rest of this year to prove himself.

Right On.

 

[Guest]

If Brodie was in the backfield right now, we would be close to unbeatable.

 

[Guest]

Tyler Watts was all heart, I like JPW, but our best for the decade so far is Brodie. To think that he did as well as he did and never really had anything resembling a good offensive line is amazing.

 

[JoshB]

For now I'm going with Tyler Watts. He was a winner. Brodie was overrated and JPW still has the rest of this year to prove himself.

how was Brodie overrated, please explain. i love Tyler Watts too but u call him a winner, compare their records as starters.

 

[BigAl]

If Brodie was in the backfield right now, we would be close to unbeatable.

Brodie ranks up there somewhere near Namath. I don't think we're ever know how good Brodie really was.