I agree that this might be some sour grapes from Miss State, and perhaps even Coach Urban Meyer. At the very least, it sounds like Newton had contact with this agent, so there is something that happened that shouldn't have. I'm not saying he's ineligible, but Auburn should go ahead and sit him to show that they respect and acknowledge the NCAA's concern over his eligibility. By playing him, and sure, they can't win if they do, they can't win if they don't, they are showing a disregard for the rules around his status.
I can't see Auburn having a good way to deal with this. It's guilty before innocence in the court of public opinion, and most times with the NCAA.
Cecil admitted to speaking with Rogers during their official visit to Mississippi State. He said as an MSU alum he felt that Rogers would be a good resource of information regarding the program, university and surrounding area.
Auburn should, and would, sit him if there were NCAA concerns regarding his eligibility. Several sources of information, including ESPN this morning, have stated there are no concerns regarding Cam's eligibility. To sit him without any proof, or suspicion from anyone of consequence, would be unfair to Cam and his teammates.
Cecil isn't commenting on it because he's been told by the NCAA and Auburn not to. If he had anything to hide he wouldn't have turned over his church financial records, he was under no obligation to do so.
The bottom line is as of this morning ESPN is NOT reporting that the NCAA is investigating Cam Newton or Auburn. They are investigating the report brought to them by Mississippi State.
A few quotes of interest from Sports Illustrated:
"To be clear, as of Thursday evening, neither Auburn, nor Newton nor his family has been publicly accused of any wrongdoing. Anything to the contrary is assumption or innuendo, and Newton is not being withheld from competition."
"As of now, we have no evidence that Rogers made any such demand to Auburn on behalf of Newton, or that any dollars ever changed hands. We only know what
didn't happen -- that Mississippi State did not take up Rogers on his offer."
These agents are the underbelly of the college football world. It seems to me that by reading the articles from reputable sources, the "agent" and his dealings with Mississippi State are at the center of the investigation--not Cameron, not Auburn. Until there is any evidence that this kind of offer was made to and accepted by Auburn, this still remains a non-issue. Hell for that matter until there is any proof that the conversation with State was actually sanctioned by the Newton family, this remains an investigation of the dealings of a person claiming to be an agent and who has already gotten into hot water for lying about it before.