I could not disagree more.
Using Bowls are a horrible guage for measuring conferences and teams.
Teams spend a 12-13 game season to establish who they are and where they rank, but then you will trump four months of games with one game played in the craziest of circumstances.
With Bowls you have a month + to all but change who you are and get healthy. Teams spend a week away from home dividing time between prcatice and visit to Disney World. Some teams play with entirely new coaching staffs. Heck, two left the country to play. Bowls are to teams what Spring Break is to students...and neither with give you a good idea of what the groups are like 51 weeks out of the year. (No Tennessee players arrested...do you see what I mean?)
Take Virginia Tech/Tennessee. What does that game say about how good Virginia Tech is compared to Alabama. ANSWER: Nothing, but the temptation is to think that VT would beat Bama...and yet that is not the case. How bad could Bama have beaten Tennessee if Bama has 4 weeks off before playing the Vols like the Hokeys had? These considerations are not factored into the casual conference vs. conference comparisons that happen this time of year.
Take Florida/Cincinnati. Do you suppose the Gators were plaing inspired, and do you suppose that might have been spawned by the revelation that CUM may be coaching his last game? Do you suppose the Bearcats were a bit shell-shocked and distracted by having their coach bolt on them, and this after being denied a shot at the title after the best season in the history of the school?
And don't get me started on the fairness of the match-ups. The SEC doesn't get the joy of 10 Bowls without being paired as the underdog here and there. What other conference is offering up its #10 team so that a #10 vs a #10 can be played? Heck, we play 3 Conference Champions.
Ark vs. ECU SEC #7 vs. C-USA #1.
UT vs. VT SEC #6 vs. ACC #3.
Kentucky vs. Clemson SEC #8 vs. ACC #2.
OleMiss vs. OK State SEC #5 vs. BIG12 #3.
S.Car. vs. UConn SEC #10 vs. Big East #5.
Auburn vs. Northwestern SEC #9 vs. Big 10 #5.
LSU vs. PSU SEC #3 vs. Big 10 #2.
FLA vs. Cin SEC #2 vs Big East #1.
BAMA vs. Texas SEC #1 vs BIG12 #1
UGA vs. TA&M SEC #4 vs. BIG12 #9
Apples-to-Apples. Conference standing-to-Conference standing, we are underdogs in 8 games, favorites in 1, and correctly paired in 1.
That's facing teams that averaged finished 2.3 ranking positions better in their conference that our teams did in the SEC. And we went 4 and 4 in the role of underdog. We won the game we were supposed to win, and are favored in the rightly paired match-up to come.
If Bama wins, the SEC would have gone 6-4 in games where we should have gone 2-8...if Bowls were a good measuring tool for comparing Conferences.