I like Scout because they have lists of players who are planning on visiting...I like Rivals because they seem to update their rankings a lot more frequently. But neither are dead on accurate. And another thing to take in to account, that they don't take in to account, is what kind of system that the prospect is going in to. Terrence Cody was a 4-star on Scout and a 3-star (5.6) on rivals. Obviously both of these are off-base...they just weren't able to see what kind of impact a body like TC's would make in a Saban-style 3-4 defense.