I get what you're saying here, Jill.
Here's where I tend to tread carefully. How often have you seen a Bama fan say the Tide was a TD away from playing for an NC? Coulda.
How many times have we seen people talk about OJ and the Ole Miss game. Shoulda.
Or, if the Tide had won against Ohio State what would Bama have done in the NC game? Woulda.
Reminds me of 2005 when Closner went down and we ended up with Britt (?) at center for the LSU game? Now, there wasn't a damn thing about Closner that made him what I consider to be an SEC center. In fact, I thought he (and his coach) were a joke. But, many were quick to hypothesize if JB was playing against LSU (and Auburn) we'd have won those games.
Coulda, woulda, shoulda.