Kiffin's big decision
Cecil Hurt
TideSports.com Columnist
Watching last night's State of the Union address, one obvious conclusion was that approval ratings can be fickle things.
Which leads us to Lane Kiffin.
No figure in football seems to cause more fluctuations in the affections of the fan base where he is coaching.
In some cases, most notably at Alabama last year, he isn't really wanted in the first place (at least not by anyone not named Nick Saban, also known as the Majority of One) in other instances, like at USC, he is wanted. Then he stays at a job for a while - usually not a long while - and then the fan base really wants him to go (Oakland Raiders, USC) or they really want him to stay (Tennessee, judging by the angry reaction when he bolted).
Alabama fans, having had a few weeks to digest the Sugar Bowl, want him to come back for another year to tutor another new quarterback. At least most of them seem to want that.
It's hard to think of another coach in football, especially another's assistant coach, who inspires such strong emotions.
Even in San Francisco, where he hasn't taken a job, the buzz is that he carries too much baggage from his Oakland days, although I personally think that anyone should be forgiven for whatever happened in their days with the Raiders, sort of like pardoning the convicts on Devil's Island for doing what they had to do to survive.
Nick Saban's Tuesday comments on Kiffin didn't sound like anything had been settled. If he was a recruit, rather than the offensive coordinator, he would be what the analysts call a "soft commit." The shirt says Alabama, but who knows what the hat will say on Signing Day?
As Saban said, it's up to Kiffin to decide what the best option is for himself and his family. The NFL is the NFL after all. People in college football hotbeds like Tuscaloosa or Columbus or South Bend tend to think of the college game as a better gig, but most of America feels otherwise.
The NFL, like it or not, is the big show. That doesn't mean you automatically have to go when the professional league calls.
Saban, for one, went for a couple of years, didn't seem to like it all that much, and has returned to thrive in college ball. Pete Carroll, who will be taking a team to the Super Bowl in a couple of weeks, failed at one NFL stop, came back for a great run as a college coach and now is on top with the Seahawks. Every career path is different.
I do think that his stint at Alabama has been good for Kiffin. He said the same thing in New Orleans. It took him out of the spotlight, let him do the things he is good at doing and avoid some of the things that seem to be problematic for him.
His approval rating, as noted above, is about as high it has ever been, at least since his assistant coaching days at USC. Frankly, they are higher here than they are going to be in San Francisco unless the 49ers stop their skidding in a big hurry. If he goes to work for Jim Tomsula, he is going to be a bigger name and more recognizable face than his head coach. I had to Google "Jim Tomsula." Nobody Googles Lane Kiffin.
Would that be a good thing, better than another year polishing the resume at Alabama? That's what Kiffin eventually will have to decide.
https://alabama.rivals.com/content.asp?CID=1727576