rolltyroll said:
. He obviously can't see that the majority of color analysts in any sport are former players that were not the "cream of the crop", hence, they are in the booth. That's just the way it is. Ex-Gary D., Kirk Herbstreet, Mark May, Jim Donnan, Bill Curry, Kyle Petty, Wally Dallenbach, and on and on.
I was embarrassed by Shane's phone call.
FWIW,
Mark May. 2 time All-American, winner of the Outland Trophy and selected for the Pro-bowl in the NFL.
Gary Danielson- 13 years in the NFL and still one of the top 20 in all time passing yards.
Kirk Herbstreit- 4 year letterman at Ohio State. Started in '92 and passed for 2000 yards in a option system. All conference and MVP are just some of the awards he received in college.
Jim Donnan - The Marshall you probably don't remember of the 1990's was Donnan's brainchild. He won a National Championship there, was runner-up for the NC 2 or 3 times. He was the OC under Switzer that won the NC at Oklahoma. In college, ACC Player of the Year. Hell of a QB at NC State.
Bill Curry - The fact that he coached at Alabama at one time had a 26-10 record while here is a statement in itself with it comes to resumes and commenting on college football. Add to that ACC Coach of the year once, SEC Coach of the Year twice, National Coach of the year once. 9 years playing in the NFL, All Pro two years at Center. Had a few years coaching in the NFL as well.
What the hell race car drivers have to do with color football analyst, I have no clue!
Bottom line, if you take the names you have listed as examples, you'll see all of them have great resumes to be analyst in their positions.
More than qualified...just victims of fans who like to complain about different things they see and hear in their broadcasts.
I'm not a big fan of Lou Holtz. But, he has the resume to be there.