🏈 Bama loses by 3 on the road and drops seven spots. Michigan loses by 29 at home and drops 1?

[rocknthefreeworld]

I still don’t understand why the BCS formula wasn’t used instead of this committee. We all know that when you get that many people in there, you are going to get that many varying opinions plus a few wanting to call in favors. I’m fine with the playoff, just use the BCS formula.

They wanted humans to be able to adjust things to keep a rematch championship from happening again. That is 100% why they have a committee now. And 100% why Bama was dropped so hard for losing last week.

 

[bamascw]

Where's the line drawn on the number of good losses? My god, look at A&M this season. They've got five losses on the season to teams that were ranked (at game time) #1, #8, #1, #4, and #2.

Oh I could not agree with you more. The "good loss" logic is "LOSSED" on me....
I think you have to bypass the good loss once you have multiple but that is just me. You know how it goes with Bama, nobody likes dominance.

 

[TerryP]

Oh I could not agree with you more. The "good loss" logic is "LOSSED" on me....
I think you have to bypass the good loss once you have multiple but that is just me. You know how it goes with Bama, nobody likes dominance.

Since we're on A&M for a minute. I've seen it suggested we take a look at the Aggies and put them in a hypothetical role of playing Clemson's schedule.

Would A&M be undefeated if that were the case?

 

[planomateo]