Easy choice for me.
Different context: I'm not a "fan" of The Citadel. I've nothing against them though I've questioned decisions in the past. It's really too far to drive for a ball game (yeah, 20 miles) on a Saturday afternoon/night. It's not worth the trouble.
My civil lawyer? A Citadel grad. I'm not a fan of his school: every one in the judicial system happens to be. Well, just about every one.
When I can't figure out the answer to an agronomical question/problem I have here? My call, to a guy who owns a company and that's their specialty. AND, he's an agro guy with a degree from ... Clemson AND Auburn.
Go with the best; ignore the rest.