http://www.saturdaydownsouth.com/al...ng-to-bama-still-looks-right-for-jacob-coker/
Did Jacob Coker make the right decision coming to Alabama?
Christopher Smith
March 18, 2015 @ 7:26am
204
SHARE ARTICLE
2
TWEET ARTICLE
When Jacob Coker lost a close competition to Jameis Winston to become Florida Stateās starting quarterback prior to the 2013 season, no one anticipated heād wait this long to get his turn.
Alabama needed a replacement for senior AJ McCarron, and it seemed like the Tide preferred not to turn to fifth-year senior Blake Sims, a career backup with 39 passes to his credit at The Capstone. At least that was the perceived inference when coach Nick Saban convinced Coker to transfer to Tuscaloosa at this time last season.
FSU coach Jimbo Fisher asserted that Coker is a better talent than any of Bamaās recent quarterbacks. Fisher implied that Coker could outperform McCarron and Greg McElroy, both of whom won national championships for the Tide.
But a funny thing happened in Tuscaloosa. Sims started the season opener. And the next game. And the next. Soon the year ended. Coker had thrown 59 passes his entire junior season, all as the backup. Sims performed better than anyone expected, teaming with Amari Cooper and new offensive coordinator Lane Kiffin to thrust the team to an SEC championship and a College Football Playoff berth despite a well-below-average Alabama defense.
Scuttlebutt emanating from Alabama indicated that Coker hadnāt grasped the playbook, didnāt seize control of the huddle and generally came across as unprepared to take advantage of the opportunity. In laymanās terms, at least from a limited outsiderās perspective, it sounds like he shrunk from the moment. To be fair, itās not easy to pack up mid-college career, head to a new campus, learn the names of dozens of new teammates and coaches, absorb the playbook and in a few monthsā time enter the field as an All-SEC quarterback.
Given everything thatās happened at both Alabama and Florida State, it does beg the question: Would Coker be better off had he stayed in Tallahassee?
Much like Francis Underwood on the Netflix show āHouse of Cards,ā no one bought it when Winston announced heād return to the Seminoles in ā15. Indeed, heās going to be one of the first names NFL commissioner Roger Goodell announces on April 30. Winston was going to start for FSU in ā14 unless he was behind bars or the team discovered a Peyton Manning clone with NCAA eligibility. (Even then, the Seminoles may have found a way to start Winston.) But Coker may have predicted heād get a chance in 2015 if he stayed.
Winston did face a one-game suspension against Clemson last season. Redshirt sophomore Sean Maguire led FSU to an overtime win before giving way to Winston. Florida State didnāt defend its national title, but still made it into the College Football Playoff. Now Maguire
looks like a strong bet to start at quarterback for the Seminoles in 2015.
Coker was ahead of Maguire on the depth chart in ā13, and likely wouldāve started that game against Clemson and then entered this offseason as the favorite to win the job. Would he be in a better position at FSU, entering his fifth season in the same offense and with one start to his credit? Or is he in a better place after last yearās disappointment at Alabama, teaming up with a great coordinator in Kiffin after being forced to examine how he can get better?
Itās difficult to blame Coker for his decision to transfer. Beyond winning games, or setting up NFL careers, the next priority for big-time college football players is to get the opportunity to play. Lose a competition to become the starting cornerback and you can still see the field covering kicks, if not on defense when the team deploys extra defensive backs. Fail to earn a starting job as an offensive lineman and maybe you can play during extra points, staying ready in case of an injury to one of five different starters.
But backup quarterbacks in major college football have little opportunity. Barring injury, they spend their days getting practice reps without any real defensive pressure and while throwing to sixth, seventh and eighth receiving options.
Both Alabama and Florida State are in position to continue to win games in bunches, though the Tide should enter the season with a slight advantage in the major polls. Both teams lost impact offensive skill players after last season, but can place confidence in a proven offensive system.
Touted college athletes arenāt known for patience and strong self-awareness. It seems likely that being forced to identify and correct his weaknesses for a year in relative solitude could make Coker into a better quarterback than heād be if he got thrust into the noise of a starting job on a national championship contender last season. To his credit, Coker
handled last season with class, keeping his head down and his mouth shut and supporting Sims.
āI think thatās why everyone respects him so highly is because when Blake went out there to start there was never a time where you saw him on the sideline like pouting,ā senior center Ryan Kelly said,
according to 247Sports.com. āHeād be the first guy ā I remember we scored against Florida and he was the first guy over there high-fiving and jumping up and down, so just a team guy that everybody wants to be around.
āQuite frankly, from the quarterback, thatās what you want. I think heās done a great job so far, and I think heās had a positive attitude.ā
Thereās no definitive answer to whether or not Coker is better off in Tuscaloosa or if he wouldāve benefitted more by staying at FSU. And letās not get ahead of ourselves like we did this time last year. Coker still must do enough in practice to enter the Sept. 5 game against Wisconsin as the teamās starting quarterback. But he may win the job by default, as heralded true freshman Blake Barnett just got to campus in January, and the trio of other players at the position have to this point looked like nothing more than backups.
āObviously when he started last year, it was a whole new offense to him, everyone was ahead of him and right now I feel like heās a lot more comfortable and confident with what weāre doing,ā Saban told the media Friday.
āWeāve tried to make it a little easier with what weāre doing at that position so that they donāt have the burden as some of the guys in the past have had so that the inexperienced players can develop a little more quickly and weāre hopeful Jake will be able to do that and weāre pleased with where he is right now.ā
Kiffin and Cokerās teammates have backed him and downplayed last year, seemingly defending Coker to the media, making excuses for him without even realizing it. But it sounds like the adversity he faced on the field in 2014 has forced Coker to be a stronger, more vocal leader and a more studious player.
āHeās obviously more mature,ā Kelly said. āObviously being a fifth-year guy, youāve seen the ins and outs of college football, and I think heās done a great job stepping into a bigger leadership role. Last year, being his first year, itās just hard to step into a role like that when you donāt really know a lot of guys. Now that heās had a little bit of time to meet everybody and kind of hang out and build peopleās trust up, I think heās going to have a good year.ā
If Coker does start for Alabama in 2015, given his physical ability and the presence of Kiffin, he could have a season as a senior first-year starter that exceeds even what Sims did last year. That delayed gratification would make it hard to argue with Cokerās decision to transfer to the Tide in ā14.