Will Tua play, and should he play?
At this point in Tua Watch 2019, the willhe- or-wonāt-he drama (or diversion) of whether Alabama quarterback Tua Tagovailoa will play against No. 1 LSU on Nov. 9, all the available physical evidence has been discussed by everyone from Nick Saban to a team of doctors from the Swedish Institute of Stockholm ā well, maybe not them although āSwedish Instituteā always sounds impressive. Doctors who have not been within a thousand miles of Tuscaloosa have given their opinion, to say nothing of all of the couch MDās who also are on the case. People who can barely change a lightbulb (my hand is raised) can explain tightrope surgery in āGreyās Anatomyā detail.
So on Wednesday, with Tua practicing against āair,ā as Nick Saban said, the speculators did the same. After all, there are not only the physical realities to be dealt with. There are also psychological ones, and even philosophical ones, a thorny path that winds past questions like āWill he play?ā to the land of āShould he play?ā
Nick Saban addressed both on Wednesday, without changing the prognosis from the constant āGame Day Decision.ā
āI know heās going to want to play,ā Saban said. āWhat I always say to the player is āI know you want to play, but can you do your job?ā ⦠and nobody knows that but the player.
āTua has always done everything around here that he can actually do to help the team. Heās always made great choices and decisions. Heās smart. Heās bright. And I donāt think he would put himself into a position nor would we want to put him in a position going forward where what he does would have any effect on his future.ā
That was part of a longer answer about whether Tagovailoaās future might be better protected by skipping the SEC Game of the Year ā or playing in it.
āI wouldnāt care if a guy was a first-round pick or had no future as a player,ā Saban said. āWe would never put a player at risk if the medical staff, the player himself and everybody involved in the organization didnāt think the guy was capable of going out there and doing his job at a high level. It wouldnāt create any value for him and it certainly wouldnāt help us.
āWeāve had a lot of players around here who have gone and done extremely well for themselves in the NFL and been high draft picks. But I guess the question would be did they create value for themselves by being great competitors?ā
āPeople still value guys who want to make the best decision about what they do. I know in the eight years I was in the (NFL), people always said āthe warrior mentality ā this guyās really tough, he plays hard and things donāt bother him, heās not going to be on the sidelines if he gets a little nicked up.ā Iām not saying every player is capable of that and Iām not saying every player is like that. But the question is āwhat really creates value for you?ā If you canāt go out there and play with any consistency and you donāt have any durability as a player, is that a positive or a negative? So thereās another side of that and I donāt really try to promote that with the players but Iām just saying there is another side to all this.ā
There are, in fact, several sides, questions that only time ānine more days for some of the questions, perhaps nine more months for some of the others ā can answer. Reach Cecil Hurt at
cecil@tidesports.com or via Twitter @cecilhurt
āI wouldnāt care if a guy was a first-round pick or had no future as a player. We would never put a player at risk if the medical staff, the player himself and everybody involved in the organization didnāt think the guy was capable of going out there and doing his job at a high level.ā Nick Saban