Which of those players were 4 and 5 star guys? Also if he doesn't have the right players to compliment them, or a deep enough bench to relieve them, it spells trouble.
You're changing the subject a bit here. The earlier comment I was asking about:
Pearl has yet to have his guys in yet, so we can't fully judge him yet.
My contention is we can judge him because those are his guys.
When Pearl took the job he went the "mercenary" route with picking up JUCO and transfer players. Out of those listed above, only one isn't a guy evaluated, recruited, and signed by Pearl.
A couple of years ago when Pearl was on the tip of a lot of Bama fans' tongues there were two reasons I was adamantly against him.
One, his actions at Iowa when he was pulling the Fulmer/Culpepper/Johaningmeir routine in basketball with recruiting. Then, he's cheating again at UT.
Two, and here's where a lot of disagreement came into the conversation:
People criticized Gottfried from losing games when the SEC was down, but praised Pearl's wins when the SEC was down. I didn't then, and still don't today, buy his time in Knoxville as a true indicator of what he brings to the table (in straight up coaching ability.)
All that said, I do think Pearl could have success at a school like Memphis. But, that thought is based a lot on what the recruiting landscape is like in the inner-city of Memphis City School's.
(BTW, if people think he's changed his ways, look no further than Purifoy with his ACT and online courses.)