Finebaum was on ESPN's podcast, ESPN College Football, with Matt Barie Sunday and he was adamantly off of the Cincy bandwagon. That was his point as well after admitting he'd been on the "get a G-5 team in" up until their game against Navy. I paraphrase him here...
"Let 'em put Cincy in and see what happens to all the expansion talk when Cincy gets blown away by the likes of UGA, or Oklahoma, or Alabama, etc."
Based on Sagarin Georgia, Alabama, and Ohio State would be double digit favorites. Cincy would be -2 against Ole Miss and I'd jump on the Rebels quickly.