B
Bama News
Tide Sports: Local News, Politics & Sports in Tuscaloosa, AL
The latest Alabama Crimson Tide sports news, scores and schedules
www.tidesports.com
There is no clear way to remove the sheer tragedy of the situation from the analysis. Alabama did not issue an immediate medical report, but several sources indicated a hip dislocation and fracture, an injury that would require far more rehabilitation than there is time remaining in the season. In other words, the Crimson Tide career of Tua Tagovailoa ā nothing short of brilliant and all too short in the end ā is over.
No one, not even Alabamaās bitterest rivals, wanted it to end this way. There will be retrospectives to come but consider that Tagovailoa started for less than two full years and shattered school records in every passing category that doesnāt require more career longevity. Whether he was āgreaterā than Joe Namath or Kenny Stabler can be debated, as can the question of whether he āaccomplished moreā than A.J. McCarron. But no one has ever been more fun for more people to watch than Tagovailoa was ā the sudden use of the past tense stings like an open wound ā or seemed so much larger than life from the first time he stepped onto an Alabama field.
Before the debate about whether Tagovailoa should or should not have been in the Alabama-Mississippi State game, be warned. The āShould Notsā are armed with the mighty weapon of hindsight, able to crumple any counter-argument with one swing.
Even Nick Saban acknowledged that in the post-game. Noting that he does not usually āmake (football) decisions based on guys getting hurt,ā Saban said that had he known Tagovailoa would be injured, he would have taken him out of the game sooner. He would also have removed the other injured players ā defensive end Raekwon Davis and wide receiver Henry Ruggs III ā before their injuries as well. No one has a crystal ball and itās doubtful that Saban could have gotten such a precise prognostication even if he had stopped the team bus on the trip over to consult with āMrs. Lamarr, Reader and Advisorāat her parlor on Highway 82.
Taking hindsight out of the equation, the question of whether to āblameā Saban hinges on a handful of suppositions and surmises. There were people in the football world who cautioned against playing Tagovailoa in Starkville. None were Alabama doctors. Some are part of the bubble-wrap brigade who want Alabamaās best players to appear in only three or four games per year ābecause they could win against Team X anyway.ā Others said that Tagovailoa didnāt appear to be at full speed after the LSU game and should have been rested. Some of those takes were sincere. The ones prefaced with āā¦ācause Bama canāt beat Auburn without himā¦ā should come with a dose of self-reflection.
Tagovailoa played an entire game on the ankle a week ago. In Saturdayās game, he went in and played well, showing no ill effects, no hindrance from the injury that would prompt Saban to remove him before halftime, a fairly common practice in coaching. You can argue that āthe score was enough,ā but where was that line drawn? At 14-0? 28-7? 35-7? This isnāt a knock on Mac Jones, put into a tough situation, but he led Alabama to three points in the second half. What if Jones had started and Alabama had lost 14-13? Or, for that matter, won by a field goal? Would Saban have been criticized for that?
There are a thousand other arguments based on outcome, or possible outcome.
What matters today is this. Football is a great sport that can also be a cruel sport. The warriors know the risks. On Saturday in Starkville, it was cruel ā and what matters now is how Tagovailoaās injury can heal, how his future can be as good as possible. Not whether Alabama ābeats Auburnā or āmakes the playoffsā or any of that. Save the cold calculations, at least for a day. Send hope in your own way, through prayer or simple positive thoughts.
āDonāt be sad because itās over. Smile because it happened,ā the adage goes.
Not today, Dr. Suess. The smiles can come later.
Be sad because itās over. All football fans should be.
