| NEWS All fields should be real grass, not fake grass - PFT


The non-contact torn ACL suffered during Super Bowl LVI by Rams receiver Odell Beckham Jr. became the latest example of a change the NFL desperately needs to make.

All turf fields should be ripped up and repacked with grass.

Simms has made this argument various times on PFT Live, and presumably elsewhere. Artificial surfaces don’t give like grass fields do. Feet get stuck when planted. The forces that don’t get pushed into the soil end up going elsewhere. Like into the joints of the leg connected to the foot.

That’s what happened to OBJ. His foot jammed into the fake field at SoFi Stadium. It didn’t give. The Newtonian reaction sent forces toward Beckham’s fairly-new ACL. It tore.

It shouldn’t have happened. It never should happen. Yes, today’s artificial surfaces are better than the cruel and unusual green cement on which tackle football was played for decades. But they’re not grass. They should be grass. All of them.

Kudos to Las Vegas, which built a stadium with a grass field that can roll in and out of the domed structure. All other fixed-roof structures should have had the same feature. All venues should have grass fields.

Even if owners have become completely desensitized to the humanity of their players, who become constantly interchanging parts of a football factory, look at it this way. If your main product is crafted by a machine consisting of various really expensive parts, and if you have only so much money to spend on those parts, wouldn’t you want the machine to be engineered and constructed in a way that protects those parts?

Stan Kroenke spent billions on his new stadium. And yet they don’t play football on grass. Surely, they could have figured out a way to do it.

What’s that? Water issues in Southern California? There’s a lake outside the stadium.

Here’s the bottom line. If Kroenke wanted to do it, it would have been done. He didn’t. And so he isn’t protecting his investment in players.

He’s not alone. Any owner who plays in a stadium that doesn’t use grass doesn’t care about protecting his or her players as much as they should. While much can’t be done to retrofit some of the stadiums with non-retractable roofs, every stadium that can convert to grass should, and all new stadiums must be built with grass fields, not fake ones.
 
Compared with the natural grass/cleat combination, the amount of strain on the ACL was 80 percent greater with the Astroturf/turf shoe, 48 percent greater with the modern playing turf/turf shoe and 45 percent greater with the modern playing surface/cleat combination.

When a similar cut, or quick turn, is made on four different surfaces, "the best strain profile is in grass/cleat combinations," Drakos said. "So, there is less force occurring at your ligament for the same cut on that particular surface using this model."

The finding is published in the January issue of the Journal of Biomechanical Engineering.

 
Never ever liked the idea of turf fields. Sure, low maintenance, but not as pretty and natural to the game as real grass. Georgia Tech went turf and it made a lot of dolks mad. Apparently it was the oldest grass playing field in the country before they went turf. I love that Alabama is grass and seriously hope we never change.
 
It's awful... and it's spreading to other sports like baseball and trickling down to the HS level more and more. As a side note, there's a company in Dadeville that manufactures it... they supplied the Super Bowl with their field turf.
 
It’s all about saving money now. Sylacauga went to it when they renovated Legion Stadium. The grass took a beating to be honest. They share with BB Comer HS and the amount of traffic was killing the grass. SHS (3 football teams and 4 soccer teams) and Comer with (2 football teams). Throw around the numbers on water, fertilizer, diesel fuel, maintenance on tractor and reel mowers, repairing turf in certain areas (PK area and goalie area of play) and finally the paint to stripe the field.
 
It’s all about saving money now.
They did the same thing here in town for four N. Charleston high schools; a combined field for all the schools and several sports.

Do you remember the thread from a few weeks ago with a softball game played on a football field and comments about how odd it looked? It's the same situation there with the field marked, permanently, for Lacrosse, football, and soccer.

It made sense, fiscally. It's a confusing mess when you look at the field driving down 526. It looks more like a McCall's packet for sewing clothes than it does any type of sports venue.
 
It's been a few years, but there was an article linking the number of leukemia (I think) cases with high school female soccer goalkeepers. Tires are not manufactured to be wallowed in, so the granules on these fields are just ground up tires.
 
Back
Top Bottom