Cincinnati Bengals quarterback AJ McCarron will become an unrestricted free agent on March 14, but the NFL doesn't agree with the decision that allows him to.
Cincinnati Bengals quarterback
AJ McCarron will become an unrestricted free agent on March 14, but the NFL doesn't agree with the decision that allows him to.
An independent arbitrator weighed the evidence presented in McCarron's grievance against the Bengals, as allowed by the league's collective bargaining agreement with its players' union, and he
decided McCarron had made his case.
NFL spokesman
Brian McCarthy told NBC Sports Radio's "Pro Football Talk" that the league thought the Bengals handling of McCarron had been correct and that the NFL Management Council had represented the team in the grievance.
Even though arbitrator Shyam Das ruled the Bengals to be in the wrong, the team won't be disciplined by the NFL.
At issue was the former
Alabama All-American's rookie season. He spent almost all of it on the non-football injury list, reaching Cincinnati's active roster for only the final three games of the season.
A player must spend at least six weeks during the regular season on an NFL active roster for the season to be accrued, that is, for it to count toward his service time, which comes into play a variety of ways in the CBA, such as in minimum salaries and free-agency qualification.
The arbitrator ruled the Bengals had kept McCarron on NFI without a good medical reason, and by doing so, had prevented him from qualifying for an accrued season. The decision restored to McCarron the year of service time.
That was important because McCarron's four-year rookie contract runs out in March. Because he now has four accrued seasons, he will become an unrestricted free agent, able to sign with any team. If the arbitrator had ruled in the Bengals' favor, McCarron would have reached the end of his contract with three accrued seasons and qualified to be only a restricted free agent, which would allow Cincinnati to retain some input on what happened next in his career.
"Pro Football Talk"
obtained a copy of Das' report on the grievance.
Cincinnati had placed McCarron on NFI before training camp started because of a shoulder issue. When the time came to reduce their preseason roster of 90 players to the regular-season limit of 53 in 2014, the Bengals again put the former St. Paul's standout on NFI.
Dr. Marc Galloway, the head team physician of the Bengals, told Das he approved keeping McCarron on NFI when the season started because he "
did not think it was in (McCarron's) best long-term interest to play football in September." McCarron wasn't clear to participate in team practices until Nov. 19, 2014, and he didn't join the active roster until Dec. 9, 2014.
Galloway also told the arbitrator that McCarron didn't receive a medical examination before being placed on NFI for the start of the regular season and that the quarterback would have passed an exam had one been administered.
McCarron joined the Bengals as a fifth-round selection in the 2014 NFL Draft. Entering the 2014 season, Cincinnati had Andy Dalton as its starting quarterback and former
Auburn standout
Jason Campbell, a veteran of 79 NFL starts, as its backup.
Without the NFI designation, McCarron would have to have been placed on the active roster to open the 2014 season (forcing the Bengals to use three of their 53 roster spots for quarterbacks) or waived (leaving him vulnerable to being claimed by any other NFL team).
"It was just business," McCarron told the Bengals' official website. "They had to do what was best for them, and I had to do what was best for me. It was never anything personal. I loved the city, loved the fans, loved everything about it. It's an awesome place to play."
Mark Inabinett |
minabinett@al.com
NFL doesn't think AJ McCarron should be an unrestricted free agent