| FTBL A few have been talking about the "best player in Alabama history" in their opinion. This is impossible for me.

[TerryP]

I loved watching Reuben Foster play. But, no more so than I loved seeing Coker play in 2015.

I can't name a player. I can name plays that make "the best."

Hell, Jake had some plays in '15!

 

[Rsedge72]

My favorite is Derrick Thomas, hands down!!!
Also feel like he was the best, in my mind!!

 

[TerryP]

My favorite is Derrick Thomas, hands down!!!
Also feel like he was the best, in my mind!!

Versus that game in Baton Rouge where SA just ran...

You look back at a career. But you also look back at that one game.

 

[Rsedge72]

Versus that game in Baton Rouge where SA just ran...

You look back at a career. But you also look back at that one game.

Yea SA was a great one too. If he played in the Saban era he’d have won a heisman…

 

[bamaledge]

Biscuit IS and will ALWAYS be my favorite.

 

[Nothing_But_A_Winner00]

I loved watching Reuben Foster play. But, no more so than I loved seeing Coker play in 2015.

I can't name a player. I can name plays that make "the best."

Hell, Jake had some plays in '15!

Loved Coker. Eddie Jackson and Minkah seemed to always make plays on the other side.

 

[UAgrad93]

David Palmer was pretty special! Javier Arenas too!
I could probably list my favorites by position. So many special guys wore the Crimson!!

 

[BamaFan334]

TJ Yeldon, Devonta Smith, and Bryce Young were my favorite. TJ was so slick and smooth. Never went down on first contact. Devonta, another smooth flowing player that looks effortless. Bryce is a guy where I knew a play would be made and it was just awesome to see how he would complete a play.

 

[TerryP]

Devonta, another smooth flowing player that looks effortless.

You'll add RW to that soon...

 

[ElephantStomp]

I said in the other thread my favorite Bama player ever, do I think he’s the best ever? No, but he is my favorite

As for the best ever? Impossible to say.

 

[rick4bama]

Biscuit IS and will ALWAYS be my favorite.

Me too!

 

[bamafan4ever]

Seth McLaughlin


















Oops. Wrong thread.

 

[BamaFan334]

You'll add RW to that soon...

Yep, I've had eyes on him for two seasons now. I kept quite about him decommitting (except to my wife), just hoping we wouldn't lose a transformative talent like him. He could really get the mental game switched from coming to play for Saban to coming to Alabama to play for DeBoer.

 

[cj6891]

Seth McLaughlin


















Oops. Wrong thread.

Savage!

 

[Bama Guy]

Impossible to answer...... but I have to go with Biscuit too.

 

[50+yeartidefan]

Favorites...namath and lee roy jordan. Of that era
Current era.....AJ and Henry

As wih best... same as @ElephantStomp Impossible to answer

Tomany great ones. ...but Devonta is close

 

[mando]

The Italian Stallion Johnny Musso for me. My first memories of Bama and #22 witht he tear away jersey. Permanently implanted on my brain and heart.

Another Johnny was memoriable also Johnny Davis. Not sure he was ever tackled for a loss. The CNS teams have had great players be the Coach Bryant era was during my teen years so they were very impactful.

 

[rick4bama]

I guess if I pick a favorite player from like 1965-68. I would say the whole team. But from 1969 - present, it would be Scott Hunter, Musso, Nathan I could keep going. That would just be the Bryant years.

 

[SnakeDoc]

Seth McLaughlin


















Oops. Wrong thread.

Are you sure it's not "best player ever" . . . To have so many bad snaps after seemingly being OK the season before to drive you to drinking?

I mean, that's definitely Seth, right?

 

[50+yeartidefan]

Us older guys really loved our BEARs players...
@rick4bama
@mando

That Musso... the way he ran....with those knees up... tackling him was painful
Saw...Johnny Davis...vs miss state.... turned corner..and a DB tried to tackle him...
That poor guy...probably still seeing stars