It wasn't a bad idea in the strict terms of basketball talent and potential. It was a bad idea in terms of his maturity in life.
This reminds me of a scene out of Yellowstone where Beth is told a lot of people stop maturing following a traumatic event in their lives. I don't know if Josh dealt with such although his statement could be read that way. I do know his level of maturity while at Bama was that of a young, very young, teenager.
Aren't you seeing a red flag when she says it happened eight times? As a psychologist, you'd think she / they'd be taking action after the first time—at the very most the second. But eight times?
Something just doesn't "click" in this whole story. I'm more than willing to admit past coverages of these types of stories have left me skeptical...a trust but verify type of approach.