🏈 PFF bad grades from iron bowl

[gc90]

List below. what surprised me was both TE, all 3 WR, and Buggs

Was expecting Minkah (despite all the love in media he has not played well this year not like his freshman year plus slow in coverage).


Offense:

TE Irv Smith Jr. (38 snaps) -- 44.2

WR Calvin Ridley (61 snaps) -- 44.9

TE Hale Hentges (23 snaps) -- 45.3

OT Matt Womack (63 snaps) -- 46.5

OG JC Hassenauer (13 snaps) -- 48

WR Devonta Smith (35 snaps) -- 49.7

QB Jalen Hurts (63 snaps) -- 67.5

WR Robert Foster (28 snaps) -- 68.8

RB Bo Scarbrough (15 snaps) -- 69.2

WR Cam Sims (28 snaps) -- 69.5

Defense:

DB Levi Wallace (80 snaps) -- 31.3

LB Mack Wilson (18 snaps) -- 41.8

DB Minkah Fitzpatrick (76 snaps) -- 41.9

LB Rashaan Evans (78 snaps) -- 46.1

CB Tony Brown (14 snaps) -- 49.1

LB Dylan Moses (62 snaps) -- 51

DB Hootie Jones (57 snaps) -- 51.2

DL Da'Shawn Hand (62 snaps) -- 52

DL Isaiah Buggs (32 snaps) -- 65.8

LB Terrell Lewis (26 snaps) -- 71.9

 

[EasyTider]

Those grades look like many of my report cards from school.

 

[OldPlayer]

What grading system is this?

 

[JoshB]

Saying Minkah "hasn't played well" is a joke.

 

[JoshB]

What grading system is this?

Pro Football Focus, they review game film and grade each player. It's based on pretty much "did you do your job." Linebacker misses a tackle, over-pursues, doesn't fill a gap he was supposed to, loses track on a receiver/tight end he was supposed to cover, etc. he gets docked points. He does those things right he gets a +1. He makes a tackle for loss, sack, pick, forces a fumble, etc. gets extra points. Some people look at it as the be-all, end-all stats. Others think its impossible to grade each player to that extend on every play.

 

[TheChief]

Is that out of 100? If so, I'd have to agree that this system thought Minkah played poorly. He may have indeed not played as well as his freshman year. He had a great freshman season is memory serves.

 

[gc90]

think about it... Minkah is third worst on defense

 

[JoseyWalesTheOutlaw]

How can Hurts grade at 67%.

 

[BamaFan334]

How can Hurts grade at 67%.

Cause he wasn't as bad as everyone is trying to paint it.

 

[EasyTider]

How can Hurts grade at 67%.

Grading Curve? Must have gotten extra credit for carrying it 18x. BTW, Tua graded 98% during warm-ups.

 

[JoshB]

think about it... Minkah is third worst on defense

Holy shit, so you actually correlated ONE game to "he had a bad year." Jesus. One game where he's still nursing a hamstring injury and pretty much every one played shitty to some extent... okay...

Grading Curve? Must have gotten extra credit for carrying it 18x. BTW, Tua graded 98% during warm-ups.

Does Tua get offended by the way you're constantly trying to crawl up inside of his ass?

 

[im4uainva]

I think it's promising that T. Lewis graded 71% in his first game, after missing the last 10, back from an injury. He will be more than ready if Bama is able to make the CFP contests.

Roll Tide!

 

[OldPlayer]

Pro Football Focus, they review game film and grade each player. It's based on pretty much "did you do your job." Linebacker misses a tackle, over-pursues, doesn't fill a gap he was supposed to, loses track on a receiver/tight end he was supposed to cover, etc. he gets docked points. He does those things right he gets a +1. He makes a tackle for loss, sack, pick, forces a fumble, etc. gets extra points. Some people look at it as the be-all, end-all stats. Others think its impossible to grade each player to that extend on every play.

I don't know how they can grade accurately when they don't know the assignments. Based on the grading criteria, if a player is on the field for 40 plays, and scores a 40, he's done pretty good. If that's the case, then here's a better representation of the grading. 100 = +1 per play

TE Irv Smith Jr. (38 snaps) -- 116
WR Calvin Ridley (61 snaps) -- 73.6
TE Hale Hentges (23 snaps) -- 197
OT Matt Womack (63 snaps) -- 73.8
OG JC Hassenauer (13 snaps) -- 369
WR Devonta Smith (35 snaps) -- 142
QB Jalen Hurts (63 snaps) -- 107
WR Robert Foster (28 snaps) -- 246
RB Bo Scarbrough (15 snaps) -- 461
WR Cam Sims (28 snaps) -- 248

Defense:

DB Levi Wallace (80 snaps) -- 39
LB Mack Wilson (18 snaps) -- 232
DB Minkah Fitzpatrick (76 snaps) -- 55
LB Rashaan Evans (78 snaps) -- 59
CB Tony Brown (14 snaps) -- 350.7
LB Dylan Moses (62 snaps) -- 82
DB Hootie Jones (57 snaps) -- 89.8
DL Da'Shawn Hand (62 snaps) -- 83.9
DL Isaiah Buggs (32 snaps) -- 205.6
LB Terrell Lewis (26 snaps) -- 276.5

 

[JoseyWalesTheOutlaw]

Cause he wasn't as bad as everyone is trying to paint it.

He must have been bonus points just for catching the snap from center. It would be interesting to see the grading by the Bama staff vs this group.

 

[BamaFan334]

He must have been bonus points just for catching the snap from center. It would be interesting to see the grading by the Bama staff vs this group.

Go ahead and jump off the ledge dude. It ain't that bad. He wasn't great, but it's not like it was so bad you need to be put on suicide watch.

 

[TheChief]

I don't know how they can grade accurately when they don't know the assignments. Based on the grading criteria, if a player is on the field for 40 plays, and scores a 40, he's done pretty good. If that's the case, then here's a better representation of the grading. 100 = +1 per play

TE Irv Smith Jr. (38 snaps) -- 116
WR Calvin Ridley (61 snaps) -- 73.6
TE Hale Hentges (23 snaps) -- 197
OT Matt Womack (63 snaps) -- 73.8
OG JC Hassenauer (13 snaps) -- 369
WR Devonta Smith (35 snaps) -- 142
QB Jalen Hurts (63 snaps) -- 107
WR Robert Foster (28 snaps) -- 246
RB Bo Scarbrough (15 snaps) -- 461
WR Cam Sims (28 snaps) -- 248

Defense:

DB Levi Wallace (80 snaps) -- 39
LB Mack Wilson (18 snaps) -- 232
DB Minkah Fitzpatrick (76 snaps) -- 55
LB Rashaan Evans (78 snaps) -- 59
CB Tony Brown (14 snaps) -- 350.7
LB Dylan Moses (62 snaps) -- 82
DB Hootie Jones (57 snaps) -- 89.8
DL Da'Shawn Hand (62 snaps) -- 83.9
DL Isaiah Buggs (32 snaps) -- 205.6
LB Terrell Lewis (26 snaps) -- 276.5

Looks like Robert Foster played 48 snaps and got a grade of 246. He got about 5 points per snap. Hassenauer got 29 per snap. Bo got 30 per snap. Those low grades? OH SNAP!