I had a hard time deciding between Doyle, Kim, & Tiffin. All where great, all won and/or helped win a lot of Alabama games. I finally went with Doyle. What I've heard called "The Six Shooter Game" on one of the Third Saturdays in October made him win it over the others in my mind. Remember? He kicked he game winning field goal, and then he made the 6 shooter gesture with both hands? I know there is a picture of him doing this somewhere, if I find it I'll post it.
The Kick is one of my favorite moments, but I still had to go with Doyle.