So who do you have in your top 5
I will go in no order
Lou Gehrig
Albert Pujols
Eddie Murray
Don Mattingly
Hank Greenberg
I will go in no order
Lou Gehrig
Albert Pujols
Eddie Murray
Don Mattingly
Hank Greenberg
Best First baseman of all time
- Thread starter doemasters
- Start date
Bill Buckner
ElephantStomp
Member
Gehrig is tops
Ferris Fain
TerryP
Staff
Personally, Steve Garvey.
Those I've seen in my lifetime:
Most think him of a second base guy but he played first a lot: Rod Carew.
I was always jealous of Eddie Murray...I can do a lot left handed including play a pretty good round of golf. I can't bat that way though.
Pujols...he's getting up there.
Those I've seen in my lifetime:
Most think him of a second base guy but he played first a lot: Rod Carew.
I was always jealous of Eddie Murray...I can do a lot left handed including play a pretty good round of golf. I can't bat that way though.
Pujols...he's getting up there.
/thread
:sauer055:
Gehrig
Bagwell
Miguel Cabrera
Albert Pujlos
Frank Thomas
Bagwell
Miguel Cabrera
Albert Pujlos
Frank Thomas
/thread
who is that :nana:
I will cut you.
Leave it to Kirk to list a barner. A barner who was mostly a DH at that.
Last edited:
Pete Rose? :icon_cheers:
Didnt he use roids?
You are on some mighty thin ice, pal.
Pujlos
Will Clark
Harmon Kilibrew
Don Mattingly
Willie Stargell
Will Clark
Harmon Kilibrew
Don Mattingly
Willie Stargell
